malayalam cinema
 
 
Home » India, News

Hannan Binth Hashim – Pride of India

14 September 2009 113 Comments

Hannan Binth Hashim, a tenth standard girl in Kozhikode, Kerala has questioned the accuracy of Einstein’s theories. Just a 14 year old girl has made a theory which can prove many existing theories as wrong. According to her Universe is a constantly changing matter.

Her ‘Absolute Theory of Zero ’states that the speed of light is not a constant while theories like ‘Big Bang theory’ , ‘Theory of Relativity’ are developed based on the concept of constant light speed. That makes a challenge to the existing theories developed by Einstein. “Discovering the hidden concepts of universe does not lie only in new scientific theories but also in the unexplained corners of old theories” Hannan stongly believes.  The young Astrophysics aspirant is all set to deliver her speech at Universities of Boston, Texas, Chicago, Massachusetts Institute of Technology and 17 other universities across the world. Hannan was guided Dr Soumya Vasudevan, a Hind Rattan award winner. According to Hannan Binth Hashim ‘Absolute Theory of Zero’ is a new mathematical concept that explains the existing theories in a different light speed.

Former President A P J Abdul Kalam, NASA, many scientists of IISc, IIMSc and many research institutes in the world has appreciated this young talent. She has participated in the NASA space camp held in August and her model rocket was launched there. Hannan will meet Mr. President of US this October in the Siemens Westinghouse Science and Technology competition for high school students.

Filed under: India, News by admin
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...

113 Comments »

  • maya said:

    Hanan congratulations. really proud of you.keep rocking….you r pride of every Indian. God bless you

  • Chi Chung said:

    This looks like a media hype. There is no institute like IIMSc. Siemens Westinghouse Science and Technology competition is open only for US citizens.

    There is no Dr Soumya Vasudevan who received a Hind Rattan Prize..

  • Khalid,calicut said:

    Best of luck Hanan, wish u all the best…. dont look back keep going…all indians are with you….

  • shihab said:

    Congrats…….. keep it up and be proud to be an Indian. May allah shower all d blessings upon u

  • ASHARAF M.K MADAPPALLY COLLEGE said:

    CONGRATULATIONS.I LIKE EINSTEIN AS MOST SCIENTIST.I KEEP EARS FOR HEARING THE NEW DISCOVERIES.

  • Akthar.s said:

    Intense de javu…about 12 year old from Bihar getting a prestigious NASA award which was not there. Pray god it wont end up like that !

  • Varghese K.P. said:

    Congratulations

  • Jijin said:

    Hearty Congratsss Hannan…..Conquer the heights of Astrophysics…..go far beyond light like Tachyons…….God Bless U……

  • Muhammed Shafeeq said:

    Excellent…!!assumption on previously assumed will be 99.99% error..

  • madhu said:

    hanan congradulations, we proud of you . God bless you

  • Latheef VP said:

    Congrads Hannan…………..

    Blessing of The Almighty willl be with you ever………

  • Gokuldas said:

    Congragulation!Brilliant move.proud of you.

  • Jeevan said:

    @ Chi Chung………….
    The news abt. Hannan has been published by reliable sources, so it doesn’t seem 2 b a hype…. As to ur doubts, i would like 2 clarify that 1) IIMSc. stands for Indian Institute of Mathematical Sciences located at Chennai, India…… 2) Though Siemens Westinghouse Sc. & Tech comp’t is open only 4 US students, Hannan has been given exemption bcoz of her excellent track records…… & finally 3)Dr. Soumya Vasudevan was awarded Hind Rattan award on Jan.25th , 2006.

  • Rajesh said:

    Well done, Hope she does have a valid Theory. I am not too sure what the mentor ( Dr Vasudevan) is doing though. One report has it that she is a medic in the US. you would expect a mentor who is a mathematitian or physicist.. not a bilogist or medic…

  • Rajesh said:

    I meant biologist…

  • Muhammed Rafeeq said:

    congradulation ……..
    hannan u done a great thing for our society especially for muslims
    u r the great one from our country …
    god bless u…

  • Kiran Pradeep said:

    Congrats! Hannan. Everyone are very much proud of you. Questioning Einstein with concrete evidence is not a simple thing. Hope you will not be caught in the ‘drain of brain’ trail of other great Indians. Then we will lose you forever.
    YOU are the Nobel Laurete of the future and Indian Youth is inspired by you.
    *GOD BLESS YOU*

  • Faisal said:

    Congrats dear….

    You bring glory to the nation. We respect your work. Its a blessing from the God almighty. Utilise it and success is yours.

  • MaLiB MaTTul said:

    Congrats!!!!!!!!!!!! God Bless U in all ur future ways

  • shiva said:

    congradulations & all the best. God bless you.

  • Sudheesh said:

    Why is my comment still awaiting moderation? Because my blog disputes the credibility of the news? I have verified the source of everything I have wrote there. There is no reason the comment shouldn’t be published.
    http://pillasar.blogspot.com/

  • shafi said:

    hanan
    u r in the correct way of Qur,anic comment to space thinking.photo biology like sciences are main contributions of Qur,an.it was the main investigation of 11,12th centuries by islamic scientific civilizations but after the westernization of knowledge, those are assasinated.
    ur attemption vl re organize the real way of Qur’anic astrophysics.
    u can reffer 4 this topic from ibnulhaitham/wikipedia like sources
    Dr SAZuhoori

  • sudhee said:

    congratulation to hanan

    you made a achivement for india. all the best wishes for you

  • neil said:

    best wishes. god bless you

  • admin (author) said:

    @ sudheesh , thought it was link spam

  • S .K SONI said:

    CONGRATS,
    MOMENTS LIKE THIS MAKES EVERY INDIAN PROUD.THANKS AND BEST OF LUCK

  • Pradeesh P said:

    Wish you all the best in the future

  • RAM said:

    HAI HANAAN FIRST OF ALL MY HEARTY CONGRATS.WHAT ALL U DONE IN UR LITTLE AGE REALLY AMAZING!WE KERALITES,ALL OF PROUD OF U KEEP UR GRAPH ALWAYS FORWARD $ STEEPER

  • Rakesh said:

    Hannah,
    What a proud moment and achivement you are heading towards!! It was all the resistance on the particles that light has to pass through the atmosphere makes it unbelievable to believe with the existing theories that the light still achive constant speed. Your assumptions, finding and the underlying concept to prove that with findings will head the current science and technological directions to a new era..
    good luck and bestwishes))

  • shourie said:

    hi congrats …Congrats…….. keep it up
    we are inspired by ur good work.
    reach greater heights in future

  • prajith said:

    hannan i really congratulate u for your invention………..Eeswaran ella anugrahavum nalkatteyennu aathmarthamayi prarthikkunnu

  • muhammed suroor said:

    really proud of you my dear sister

  • faisal vm said:

    congradulation Hanaan…
    keep it up and try to study about humen kind, not like a biology style.. but how it has made? who?, for what? etc…
    We strongly recomend you to understand Holly Qur’an, bcz there is a lots of scientific truths which no body can explore yet or miss understanded.
    by DeMAC Oman

  • muralidaran c.k. said:

    well done! My hearty congradulations Miss.Hennan Binth Hashim.,
    Thing no one can beat your knowledge except God. Keep confident move
    you will be a boon to the world.

  • Muhammed Haneefa said:

    Dear hannan

    here I could only congradulate you, thanks to almighty, may allah gives you a longest life that could be helpfull for the human being.please note, we have a reference book find it. I am praying for all goodness.

    your elder brother

    Muhammed Haneefa

  • Muhammed Najeeb said:

    Congrats Hannan, Its the time to prove the speed of light is not constant.. as Prophet Mohammed done his Israu and Miuraj, that had only attain if the light had a different speed at different time….keep exploring …sur u will succeed..because Quran live here….

  • RITHUL MOHAN.T.R said:

    jai ho….
    congrats hannan…
    go ahead…
    may almighty god be with u in ur all ventures…
    jai ho…
    we all indians will pray 4 u…
    jai hind….

  • irene said:

    Congrats hannan….your discoveries become a motivation to our young
    generation.And best wishes for your future

  • Jaseem.vp said:

    Hanan , Congratulations
    you r pride of every Indian.
    all indians are with you….
    go far beyond light like Tachyons…….God Bless U……
    Questioning Einstein with concrete evidence is not a simple thing.

  • jithin said:

    firstly congrats!!then i like to see her research papers at least her theory-”The Absolute Theory Of Zero”,i searched for it and didnt got any worthy…If you know any link please give me..

  • Abdullah Shameem said:

    Excellent! You deserve something more than congrats. May the Almighty bless you to go on with your endeavor to change the history and bring the proud to India.

  • Nissar, Riyadh said:

    Great going Hannan! We are proud of her. She is one of among the girls who are normally least bothered of the matter of things around them.

    Let Hannan be an example to the rest of us.

    Nissar

  • Bingo said:

    UR ALL IDIOTs TO THINK THIS IS ALL CORRECT..
    SOME IDIOTS IN LEADING NEWSPAPERS PLACING REPUTED INSTITUTIONS NAMES
    HERE AND THERE IN THEIR ARTICLE AND TRYING TO GIVE IMPRESSSION TO THE READER THAT ALL IS GENUINE

  • Bingo said:

    AND SOME MUSLIMS TO SUPPORT JUST BCOS SHE IS MUSLIM
    CHECK THE FACTS BEFORE U JUMP IN BASED ON RELIGION

  • Kuma said:

    About Miss Hannan Binth Hashim and her credulous press reporters Ms Anula Aboobacker and Ms Cissy Jacob who conveniently refuse to answer criticisms, I’d say:
    1. As already pointed out, the “Space School Graduate” is not a degree. Nasa Space center at Houston is an organization to promote interest in space study among youngsters. The degree they give is only informal. Anyone ready to participate in their activities for a few days may get it. The Space Center have rocket modeler software with which one can design a model and launch it provided one is willing to pay money. These things are nothing extraordinary. Definitely Miss Hannan’s parents must have known it.
    2. Reports mention several “mentors” of Miss Hannan. One of them is Prof. Jayanth Murthy of Indian Institute of Science. Prof. Murthy admits that Miss Hannan has visited IIA library but clarifies that he hasn’t had any scientific discussion with her. The relevant part of his message is quoted from Mr. Aniver Aravind (Blog “Chithrakaran”):
    “Thanks for forwarding this link to me. I will also post my comment in that site itself. This girl came to see me some months ago and told me that she had this theory that Einstein was wrong and that Kalam was impressed by her theory… Read more. She also had a write-up in the Indian Express (if I remember right). I told her that the press and Presidents were easily impressed but that ground breaking theories do not come from school kids – they just don’t have the mathematics and physics tools necessary. I advised her to continue her interest in science but that she should work hard to learn everything necessary and that I would be glad to help her where possible. That is the limit of my contact with her (other than one more brief visit and email exchange). This is what I do for any student who contacts me and have done for dozens of students.

    I am not her mentor and have no knowledge of her work. If anyone were to ask me, I would say that I do not believe in her “theory” but am happy to see her so interested in science. After this latest episode, I am much less forgiving and would believe that her story is a tissue of lies from beginning to end.

    Again, thanks … Read more for this link. Someone had forward the Malayalam paper where it first appeared and I had written to them as well as this girl but this site gives me the chance to make it public.”
    This reply is self explanatory.
    3. Another mentor mentioned is one Dr. Sowmya Vasudevan who is a Hind Rattan award winner. But there is no such name on the list of Hind Rattan Award winners. When this inconsistency was pointed out someone replied that there was one with that name who got the award in 2005. This is not true. In 2005 one Dr. Sowmya Viswanathan (medicine) got the award but not Dr. Sowmya Vasudevan. This slight alteration in the detail might have been made deliberately to thwart verification.
    3. Miss Hannan claims that she has formulated a novel theory called “Absolute Theory of Zero” and that her paper on the theory is going to be published in a journal by name “American Journal of Theoretical Physics.” The fragments of the “theory” as these are given by the reporters are nothing short of silly nonsense. Apart from this, there is an “International Journal of Theoretical Physics” and an “American Journal of Physics” but no such thing as “American Journal of Theoretical Physics” to carry the kid’s paper. When Unnikrishnan pointed out this inconsistency Ms. Ms. Anula replied that there is an “American Journal of Physics” which started publication in 1940. She doesn’t realize that her “American Journal of Physics” is not the same as the “American Journal of Theoretical Physics” of the reports!
    Apparently, the Expressbuzz reporter Ms Anula Aboobacker (19 June 2009) and Mathrubhumi reporter Ms Cissy Jacob (14 June 2009) do not seem to have sought any documentary evidence from the kid. They relied upon Miss Hannan’s words instead of asking her to produce the letter of acceptance Miss Hannan “got” from the so called “American Journal of Theoretical Physics.” Instead, they simply believed the words of a school kid, and her mother. Even after adverse remarks were aired, these reporters did not come up with any documentary evidence to absolve Miss Hannan. Nor had Miss Hannan herself, nor her mother, nor her Principal given any documentary evidence. Seeing the same article on Miss Hannan reproduced in several sites, one of her innocent supporters asserts that the news must be true since it is found everywhere on the net! He doesn’t realize that he is reading the same news reproduced in different sites. It’s astonishing to find naïve persons complaining that Miss. Hannan is being criticized unfairly.
    4. Miss Hannan claims that she got special permission to participate in the project-based “Siemens Westinghouse Science and Technology Competition” in which only US students are allowed to take part. In this matter also the reporters haven’t cited any document supporting Miss Hannan’s claim. However, I’ve contacted the Seimens people for verification of the matter and am waiting for their reply.
    5. Another claim is that Miss Hannan is joining MIT. How can a 10th standard kid without qualifying SAT and IELT even apply for admission to MIT? Have the reporters verified whether she has qualified these tests or not? Or has the MIT too exempted Miss Hannan from qualifying SAT and IELT? If they had, is there any evidence to the effect?
    To sum up: Miss Hannan is either a fraud or a highly imaginative kid who has mistaken her fantasy for reality. Please don’t spoil the kid by dancing to her tunes. Save her from her fantasies and guide her along the right path towards the study of science. Miss Hannan must come to terms with reality. She may grow out of her fantasy to become a great scientist, of course not right now, but later, much later, it may take years! I wish the poor girl a bright future.
    I request her reporters Ms Anula Aboobacker and Ms Cissy Jacob either to defend their reports or to tend a public apology in the matter.

  • MANU PRAKASH said:

    Hearty congratulations to the genius. Best wishes…….. Be the modern Einstien and become the glory of INDIA.

  • JK said:

    Thank you Kuma. You have got it all right. We had a discssion in Medical College Calicut about the veracity of the claims of Hannan two months back. The tall claims of hannan were immediately identified as least likely to be true by our logical minds.A quick search of the net had confirmed her claims to be false and our group had rubbished them. Now we hear that a media house has provided (probably unknowingly), a perfect platform for hyping her claims. This is the same media group which had hyped Ramar’s invention of herbal petrol years back. We all know what came out of the Ramar petrol. I can speculate with reasonable certainty that Hannan is not going to be any different. Thank you Kuma once more!

  • Rasheed said:

    Congrat.. Hanna..
    G

  • Lourdez,California said:

    She is indeed a great genius and I am lucky to have met her for a conference we had in last may 2009,Chicago
    Hanaan You are nt the inspiration of muslims alone,but to your country India, so does U.S and the world.
    We need you …your discoveres
    You will make out my dear
    Gud Luck!
    All who claims falsity doesnt know you as how much we came 2 noe..
    u trly deserve more height
    GOOO ON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    WISH YOU ALL THE BEST WISHES!!!!!!!!!

  • FUAD mfm, valapattanam said:

    best of luck…………….

  • althafali said:

    congratulation hanan allah will help you in your future movement

  • Akbar said:

    India and Even The World with you….
    May The Almighty Bless You and make your future a GreEaT SuCcEss
    We proud of You India’s Daughter….
    Go on…Trust as..We are here… Behind You…..

  • nisha said:

    After reading the comment of KUMA some doubts had arrived out of her..lets just wait and watch………….

    Anyway it will be very cruel if we do not appreciate this small girl for her efforts.First of all we should keep in mind that she is a small kid who need support rather than blames…………

  • muhammadshahar said:

    assalamu alaikum,
    i am hearty congratulates u keep confident move u will boon in d world god bless u

  • Ashok said:

    Dear Hannan,
    Congrtas..we are proud of being a malayalee…Coz o u……………….

  • Mukundankutty AG said:

    Dear Hanan,

    Congratulation, We proud of You, God will be with you for every time.

    A G Mukundankutty
    Kochi-20

  • anshad abdu said:

    Vishwasikkaan kazhiyunnilla…..

    U ar we are proud of being a malayalee

  • akhila nath said:

    really marvolous hannan…….v r proud of u

  • yasir yousuf said:

    XONGRATS ……..PROUD OF U….

  • yasir yousuf said:

    ASSALAMU ALAIKKUM….
    CONGRATS ………….HANAN………….WE R REALLY PROUD OF U…..IN UR 10TH STD.,LIKE ME U GOT A GR8 ACHIEVEMENT…………..
    MAY GOD BLESS YOU…..

  • ryu said:

    i admire your interest on physics but your ideas are highly imaginative with out any mathematical base theoritical physics do really need intutions but it should alo be an existing one with out knowing the base of physics it cannot built more ….i hope u understand that.

  • SADIQUE said:

    WHATS YOUR E MAIL ID

  • sanjay said:

    keep rocking hannan

  • bsheer kalathil said:

    beein a malabary i am proud of u my little sister

  • shami kalathil said:

    the gerat little genius we are proud of u !

  • Sherbina sherin said:

    Hi dear ,Congrates on Your Success. There’s something to be said for finishing what you started- Way to go! Though u are travelling on the right path, if u take unneccessary breaks others will push u back.
    God fulfill all your wishes what you want in your life.Hannan go ahead…..

  • Joby said:

    I proud of you my sister… becouse we are an indians… My parys always with you…

  • MRIDUL MEHRA said:

    ITS A SHAMEFUL ACT…CHEAT LIKE HANNAN DEFAME INDIA N MALIGN THE IMAGE OF A RELIGION…SHE HAS BEEN PROVED TO B A CHEAT…ALL HER CREDENTIALS R FAKE….HER PARENTS R INVOLVED IN ALL THAT NONSENSE N FORGERY….

    SHAME ON YOU..HANNAN..

  • hany said:

    really great hannan…..God bless u …do the best.u r an asset!!!

  • Vinod said:

    Its a joke that many of the readers are using this news to promote their religion rather than trying to find out the truth in it!!!!! This is the attitude which pulls us backwards in our race for development.

  • THASNEEM.A.R said:

    ASSALAMU ALAIKUM HANNAN BINTH HASHIM. GOOD LUCK FOR ALL OF YOUR COMING PRESENTATIONS.I AM NOT GETTING ANY OF YOUR PAPERS.I WOULD LIKE TO READ YOUR PAPERS. CAN U PLEASE SEND ME SOME PAPERS.

  • samir said:

    @Jeevan in 2005 the award winner was Sowmya VIshwanathan not sowmya vasudevan

  • Muhammed Haneefa said:

    Kuma if you cannot encourage any one dont discourage; if she give little sight leave her own way

  • hafiz said:

    congrats

  • kukku said:

    I also beleave this is just media hype.But i’d like 2 appreciate HANNAN 4 her interest in science.Wish u a bright future, friend.

  • arp said:

    criticism is good to read for heart deceased people, when it is not trying to know completely about ms. hanan then it hurt more, i am sure that ms. hanan donot want any publicity ,wealth or any command from any one bec she is from reputed and blessed family, just need help from god the almighty to prove the subject to concerend authority not to the fools, whatever she want prove not any particular religion but it is for all humanbeings here after so donot waste time for crticism with the satans whispers about her it become more jelous and the heart will be conjested even for breath , god bless her, the time will prove it, wait and see

  • Shabari Dubai said:

    Dear readers, Miss Hanan story was fabricated by one of the popular Malayalam news paper who says Power of real newspaper (Yadartha Pathrathinte Shakthi) Any way the same news published in an English daily by copying Malayam news and English journalist is terminated from his job just because of this fake news.
    The malayalm daily who published this news do this kind of invention , I hope you guys not forget what happen to Ramar’s petrol so for them its not a new for cheating its readers and society .

    MIIT is declared that she is not their student or MIIT not offered anything to Miss Hanna.

    Nasa Certificate (what Hannan says ) its not a degree that will issued to each student who is participating NASA’s highs school student program.
    For Attending this program you have to pay just RS 200,000 to nasa and all the visa and other legal formalities will be prepared by an association named world tour based in Chennai

    Any way I congratulate Hanan that in this small age she succeed to cheat the people of india because this type of cheating cant do so easy because she need some research in internet . May be her parents will be behind this drama if her parents are the real culprit I urge them to prosecute by the law or if all this did by hannan just forgive her and pray for her that to help her become a space scientist

  • Sereena said:

    Dear Hanna,
    Because of your naughty act you cheated all Indians and muslim world. Now try to be a real space scientist instead of fabricated storeys. World realise the way you cheated them so take it as a challenge and work hard and you can achive your goal .
    Same time try to respect the legends like Dr. A.P.J Abdul Kalam and get their blessing .

    Allah wil forgive you my kid.

  • AnOoP said:

    Why we malayalees always believe in media hypes? I was forced to read about this girl after many of my pals keep on asking me about this child prodigy. every one seems to be charged up …malayali girl, indian , muslim etc. As a person who spent a significant amount of time in my career to understand relativity theorems (special and general), all this hype is absurd.

    You can’t simply disprove relativity theorems (or any theorem). by a single statemet. I saw an interview with her recently and she is simply blabbering non sensical statements. It more sounded like a science fiction to me becuase science has its own way of validating things and this little girl didn’t seem to following any of those.

    1) Where is the maths?

    2) Where is the proof?

    3) Where did she publish?

    4) Who appoved this?

    5) What the bloody hell Allah and Qran to do with Astrophysics?

    Yes I agree that, she might be an exceptionaly talented girl who is keen to pursue Astrophysics as a career. Rather than getting into media stunts, i reckon her parents should had guided her through proper channels

  • hakim said:

    khuda aapko khush rakhe,aap unhi desh ka roshan kijiye….

  • baburaj said:

    Mr.Anoop,

    Be polite while responding , don’t be an idiot
    and try to learn the existence of GOD

  • Nelson said:

    MIT or any US Universities can wavier their admission requirement depending on the candidate.

  • AnOoP said:

    Baburaje,
    You mean to say, we are supposed to support all fraudulent claims. I have nothing against Islam, what I told in my last post is by making bogus claims; this girl put all of us in back foot and many people started praising this as Allah’s wish etc. I guess Allah is not the culprit in this, it’s the media makes these hypes without validating facts. Existence of GOD is a different topic. I guess you are from the same pseudo science school who believe Ravanan invented Air bus, Krishna was aware of nuclear fusion, Mohammed told about relativity theory etc. I don’t know how these religious fanatics becoming successful in misinterpreting stupids like you.

    Okay now you can prove

    E= mc^2+Q

    Where Q is Quranic constant; Allah’s mysterious energy constant term added before the big bang

    Reference

    1) Quran – page 222, section2

    If you can prove this – its allah’s wish , if you can’t – that’s also allah’s wish. As simple as that 

  • Legend said:

    My dear friend Anoop,
    Abt the above mentioned pseudo science school, u must consider one fact that

    More than 70% of the people in india believes rama build a bridge to lanka(and that too with the help of monkeys),

    And majority of the people in the world believes jesus cured a blind with a touch …(no tym to mention the rest of such beautiful stories)…

    Just mentioned a few bcz i wanted to inform u that more than 99% or world population graduated from that pseudo science school that u mentioned…rest all are considered as Athiest(nireeshwaravaadhi) .

    So, u r not just mentioning baburaj and few of his fellow classmates, but almost whole of the world population..

    The question is, which percent of this world population u belong to? the 99 or 1?

  • AnOoP said:

    Legend,

    Santhosh Madhavan claimed he cured many blind women with a touch/pooja. Do you believe he is next Jesus?

    As I said earlier existence of god is a different topic.

    How do you work out this 99 vs 1 % Our neighbouring state – a major slice of DMK followres in tamil nadu never studied in your school.

    Well I have several difficulties in digesting religious affiliation of ‘Gods’ – my logic can accommodate an omnipotent god upto a certain extend.

    Why a human interface is necessary for god’s existence? why we have to cite violent fantacies from epics to spread psudo science? Let this girl do some fantastic research and make all of us proud.

    So tell me who is the best god
    1) Jesus
    2) Allah
    3) Ram

    Who is the best living ‘human god’?

    a) Saibaba
    b) Amrtanandamayi
    c) Sri Sri

    Hint: you have to use relativity principle to convince your answers.

    PS: the cold war between a, b and c is far worst than Obama and Osama

  • mitshan said:

    stop these kind ff bullshit….!!…. juz believe god is everywhere…… as energy is everywhere in scientific view…….lyk that….
    hannan is a very talented girl…….u juzz proud f her….otherwise do ur own work
    alll the best hannaaan ;) ..

  • looloo said:

    bt is it really proving einstein wz wrong????????? or may be some media creation??? dnt kno……

  • Legend said:

    Let us not deviate from the topic….
    this discussion is going out of track…
    as u said, let that girl escape from the fantasy world created by the media and continue with her work..if she have the potential,she will make us proud; not just in a media hype, but in real…

    And just bcz i dont want to leave any questions unanswered,
    let me say something to Anoop….

    abt ur first question…
    ur options r not enough to answer it dude..
    first of all, Christ is not god…he is considered as the son of God…
    so he cant be even considered as an option under the topic “GOD”

    And Rama, he is just one of the hundreds of gods and cant even point out who is best among them…

    Abt Allah, i just dont know more enough other than he is considered as one and only one god by muslims…i am not commenting on rest part that i am not aware of…

    so, that question is useless…

    and abt human gods…
    i just cant help saying that theres no such species among human race…
    and whatever magics they do, whatever tricks they show,
    i wont believe in the concept of Human God…

    (thank god that david blane or copperfield or howdini was not an indian, or else, they might also be considered as human gods…u just have to see their magic tricks…LOLzz)

  • UnPolarized said:

    Hi everyone,

    I would like to comment something in this topic.

    Hannan might be a talented girl. That is only why she got an opportunity to take part in “NASA space camp”. Anyway very very talented than most of the other kids around.

    She also got a courage to challenge Einstein, eventhough she could have another thought before challenging someone like Einstien. She is just 14/15 yr old. Need to be matured to THINK twice before claiming something. if she has got 100% proof, or already proved her findings then its fine to challenge anyone eventhough he is a GodFather of science.

    If they claim is something that doesnt she deserves or money can buy or excagerated, its very very bad and anyone have the right to question all those she or her family claims, provided she should be encouraged(She has got some extra ordinary talent i guess). But still people can make Hannan and her family understand where they are going wrong without discouraging them.

    If people let anyone claim things that they dont deserve, 100s of people follow the same thing. So anyone can question if they gave false information to the public. One more thing… some one who is questioning should also have enough proof to claim she and her family has provided false information to the media/public. Otherwise the people who is questioning will be doing the same thing like the Hanans family is doing (if her family did something wrong).

    Also our local Journalist are not professional, they just publish wat they hear, doesnt need any proof or bother to investigate. They need to be changed first. If they are spending few hours with the Hannans family with some investigation mind, they could have got enough proof and reference to know what all informations are valid and what all are exagerated. Anyway it will take time to find a change in our journalism.

  • NextDoorNerd said:

    Matrubhumi Malayalam Daily apologised for falsly reporting this news without much verification http://nextdoornerd.blogspot.com/2009/10/finally-clouds-are-breaking-up-hannan.html

  • sharfu said:

    Its very grat to hear you as a great scientist. may god help you inshah allah.

  • Noushika said:

    Dear Hanaan,

    See how people are anxious and eager to know about ur research works. Its quite natural that critisism will be always there until everything come out of the shell and become crystal clear to all.You have started by your own on a very limited platform and reached upto here. We all are optimistic with your talent and efforts. All the best.

    Some of the comments listed above remind me few lines of a poem by Robert Frost.

    The woods are lovely, dark and deep
    But I have promises to keep,
    And miles to go before I sleep,
    And miles to go before I sleep.

    Please let this talented little girl to go extra miles to achieve her target. Lets wait till everything become crystal clear.

    Hannan you have big dreams and higher ambitions. You have miles to go with your deeper commitments and greater efforts until you publish your work.

  • A P Jamal said:

    Hannan Bheti,

    Itna tak pahunji…. aur uppar jaaneke hai…

    Before that, make the things clear to the people who are very curious about you and your life…. make scense?

    Luv, Apj

  • scientist said:

    we r curios and help less against cheating .i read all those openion about hannan . from both side peoples having different openion .i also searched in wikipedia about hannan’s theory from there i didnt get any information about hannan.some scietists are believing speed of light is not constant.may allah bless u if u publish those documents instead makes rocking…

  • Arun P said:

    well i cant stop laughing after reading all these media hype and comment.does this girl atleast have the prerequisite knolwedge in basic physics and mathematics?calculus,differential equations,vector calculus(indeed she must have the basic knowledge in electromagnetic theory to properly understand special relativity)special relativity originated as a result of the wave equation being variant under the galiliean transformations,but the experimental results such as michelson morley experiment,trouton noble experiment etc proving otherwise.that is Maxwell’s equations remain true in any inertial frames of reference…a successful resolution of the problem indeed due to lorentz,not einstein is what really solved the problem.and worth mentioning are the names of poincare and minowski.einstein was just a clever synthesizer of all these solutions.there lies his genious),tensor calculus,classical mechanics?i really pity about the indian society who have absolutely no interest or knowledge in pure sciences such as theoretical physics and who are only concerned about foolish useless and absurd subjects like economics,trade,commerce etc.and it is this group of people who easily fall prey to such absurd claims and are real hindrance for flourishing and encouragement of fundamental research here…infact we have only a handful of institutions concentrating on undamental research like TIFR,IUCAA,NCRA,IMSc
    etc…here the foolish common people with low intelligence doesnt even know the difference between science and technology.everyone is telling even kalam doesnt understand her.kalam is after all an aerospace engineer.what has he to do with theoretical physics????he is not at even a scientist at all,but paying due respect to his engineering skills,he is definitely one of the best technocrats our country has relly produced.i cant stop laughing reading all this bull shit stuff in newspapers.and to all your knowledge,here is an unknown but a great theoretical physicist from kerala who is at par with einstein,dirac,or hawking.a real genious with great insight and scientific abilities.Thanu padmanabhan
    his home page:http://www.iucaa.ernet.in/~paddy/
    at least just go through his research interests and his works
    after all all science is axiomatic mere guess works about what we called reality.(now dont ask me what is reality,we will be escalating to philosophers domain then :) .here is also an article worth read by Thanu padmanabhan which has escalated into the domain of philosophers(well what we really need is a wise mixture of both,forget what stephen hawking said about the fall of philosophers from aristotle to kant).(click the title “the answer” in the link i gave before…
    i think geniouses like Thanu Padmanabhan should come forward to guide our youngsters into exciting,psychologically rewarding fields of theoretical physics,cosmology,radio astronomy,particle physics etc and save our younger generation from third rate businessmen,industries,economists,IT giants who are enslaving and destroying the.padmanabhan sir if you ever come across my post,it’s a humble request from me.people like T padmanabhan can really serve as role models and motivators for youngsters to get into exciting fields of theortical physics and not so called child prodigies and hypocrites like Hanan.
    A request to her parents:don’t spoil your child’s life for cheap fame which is worth a zilch.real reward in any scientific endeavour is that eureka moment,that flash of insight or intuition that comes from periods of tremendous hard work,whether it be solving complicated (but beautiful as dirac said)equations or after long patient hours in front of a spectrometer or other devices in a lab.
    my contact email:arunp_keralam@yahoo.com

  • Nikhil said:

    Arun,

    Theoretical physics is indeed exciting, but so are many other fields – molecular biology, genetics, cryptography….. Aren’t you a wee bit biased :-) .

    What makes you think economics,trade & commerce are “foolish useless and absurd”. They are of more practical value to a nation than theoretical physics.

    That being said, I should agree with you that even a cursory glance at that piece of ‘news’ should have been enough to reject it as hoax.

    Regards.

  • Ranjith Raghunathan said:

    This universe is really big, isn’t it? How much big? Can anyone give me a conclusion for it with 100% certainty? Then how can you say that a 14 year old girl can’t prove Einstein wrong? It is very hard to judge people with 100% certainty. Because human mind is something that science can’t explain fully.

    Edison invented electric bulb, the base prototype of every electric lamp that exist today. He had only basic education in his field. Whatever knowledge he acquired was through books and continuous experimentation. Whenever you turn the lights in your room, you must thank him. Also when you turn on your computer, or when you play your DVD player. It was his idea to record and play back on a disk other than tape. He was a person with inborn talent, not an educationally qualified scientist. A person can gain enough knowledge from people he communicates, and from books, or by closely observing the nature and creative thinking. The science and technology that you see today is not built in a single day. Our ancestors had the above practices and discovered so many things and summarized under different categories that we call as Physics, Chemistry and Math, Economics and whatever it may be. Before Newton invented and concluded gravitational principles, there was gravity in this universe. Things do come down when you throw it up. Long time before Antoine Lavoisier recognized and named Oxygen, people used to breathe air. :) . And today some people thank Lavoisier for inventing Oxygen, otherwise they’d have been dead. :) Some people of here think like this way.

    “Bhaskaracharya a (1114 – 1185) century mathematician in India rightly calculated the time taken by the earth to orbit the Sun hundreds of years before the astronomer Smart. According to his calculation, the time taken by the Earth to orbit the Sun was 365.258756484 days.” And he was not a graduate from Indian Institute of Technology or Harvard. :) What a joke right? For gods sake he didn’t born in this century. Because people of today might call him a fraud.

    Albert Einstein is known as one of the biggest geniuses of the decade. Does anyone know about his childhood? He was not excellent in Math and considered as a fool among his friends. His teacher used to underestimate him just like a few people underestimate Ms.Hannan Binth Hashim. I still don’t know Ms. Hannan Binth Hashim personally. Event I ven’t seen such a person than her photos appeared in newspaper and some blogs.

    To Arun,

    I didn’t understand why “economic, trade and commerce” are “foolish useless and absurd” and what do you mean by “save our younger generation from third rate businessmen,industries,economists,IT giants”. I dont think we can build up a successful economy with theoretical physics, astrophysics, or molecular biology only. Every researcher is a human-being so have to eat something whenever hungry. He can’t simply eat astrophysics and can’t satisfy his metabolic needs. Every citizen is a part of an Economical System and a research in Astrophysics or Theoretical Physics or in whatever subjects is a part of them. That’s why we need businessmen, industrialists, economists as long as the standard “Money” exists. If there is no concept of money, if people are following the old Barter System, what you said is okay.

    Rules were created by man, and are being destroyed or redefined by man itself. So it is my humble request for everyone, please don’t underestimate anyone, let the time prove. Please wait!!!!

    Have a nice day!!! :)

  • mmmmmmmmm said:

    want mail id of hannan. can you tell on which date matrubhumi have appologized about the news

  • unni said:

    Here is something from a blog ADIDAS
    URL is http://pappoos.blogspot.com/2009/09/blog-post.html

    ഹനാന്‍, എന്താണ് സത്യം? ചില നിരീക്ഷണങ്ങള്‍
    ഹനാന്‍ ബിന്ത്് ഹാഷിം തീര്ച്ച യായും ഒരു പ്രതിഭ തന്നെയാണ്. ഭൂമുഖത്ത് പിറന്നു വീഴുന്ന ഓരോ കുരുന്നിലും ഒരു പ്രതിഭ ഒളിച്ചിരിക്കുന്നു എന്നാണെന്റെ വിശ്വാസം. പ്രതിഭയുടെ നിര്വചചനത്തില്‍ നാം ഉള്പ്പെഭടുത്താന്‍ വിട്ടു പോയ മേഖലകളും നിരന്തരം പകര്ന്നു കിട്ടിക്കൊണ്ടിരിക്കുന്ന അറിവെന്നറിയപ്പെടുന്ന മുന്വിരധികളുമായിരിക്കണം ഏവര്ക്കും പത്രത്താളുകളില്‍ ജീവിക്കാന്‍ കഴിയാതെ പോയതിന്റെള കാരണം.
    ഹനാന്‍ പ്രതിഭയാണെന്നു പറയുന്നത് ഇന്നത്തെ മാതൃഭൂമി വാര്ത്ത യിലെ വിവരക്കേടുകള്‍ മുഖവിലക്കെടുത്തിട്ടല്ല, അതിലെ ഒരു വാചകം വിശ്വസിച്ചു കൊണ്ടാണ്. മസാച്ചുസെറ്റ്സ്ു ഇന്സ്റ്റി റ്റ്യൂട്ട് ഓഫ് ടെക്നോളജിയില്‍ ഉപരിപഠനത്തിന് അപേക്ഷ നല്കി‍യ 3600 ഓളം അന്താരാഷ്ട്രവിദ്യാര്ത്ഥിനകളില്‍ നിന്ന് തിരഞ്ഞെടുക്കപ്പെട്ട നൂറ്റിച്ചില്വാനം പേരില്‍ ഒരാള്‍ ഹനാന്‍ ആണെങ്കില്‍, അതു കൊണ്ടാണ്.
    വാര്ത്തഷ വായിക്കാന്‍ മറക്കില്ലല്ലോ.
    അബ്ദുല്‍ കലാം, ബാരാക് ഒബാമ, നീല്‍ ആംസ്ടോങ് തുടങ്ങി കടിച്ചാല്‍ പൊട്ടാത്ത പദങ്ങള്‍ എടുത്തുപയോഗിക്കുമ്പോള്‍ നേരിടേണ്ടി വരുന്ന ചോദ്യങ്ങളെപ്പറ്റി വാര്ത്തതയെഴുതിയ സിസി ജേക്കബ് ആലോചിട്ടുണ്ടോ എന്നെനിക്കു നിശ്ചയമില്ല. വിളിച്ചു പറയുന്നത് അര്ദ്ധിസത്യങ്ങളായിരിക്കരുതെന്ന നിര്ബ ന്ധബുദ്ധി സമീപകാല പത്രമാദ്ധ്യമങ്ങള്ക്ങ തീരെയില്ല എന്ന് നല്ല ബോദ്ധ്യമുണ്ടെങ്കില്‍ പോലും.
    ഇന്ന് ഓഫീസില്‍ സാമാന്യം ജോലിയുള്ള ദിവസമായിരുന്നു. അല്ലെങ്കിലും ജോലി കൂടുതലുള്ള സമയത്ത് നെറ്റില്‍ തപ്പിക്കൊണ്ടിരിക്കാന്‍ എനിക്ക് വല്ലാത്ത ആവേശമാണ്. ഇന്ന് രാവിലെ ഏഴുമണിക്ക് തന്നെ മാതൃഭൂമി വിഷയവും തന്നതു കൊണ്ട് വിഷമിക്കേണ്ടി വന്നില്ല.
    “നാസയുടെ ഹൂസ്റ്റണിലെ സ്പേസ് സ്കൂളില്‍ നിന്ന് കഴിഞ്ഞ മേയിലാണ് സ്പേസ് ആന്ഡ്ല സയന്സ്ല ടെക്നോളജിയില്‍ ഹനാന്‍ ബിരുദം നേടിയത്.” (മാതൃഭൂമി)
    ഹൂസ്റ്റണ്‍ സ്പേസ് സെന്റഭറിലെ സ്പേസ് സ്കൂളില്‍ നല്കുലന്ന ബിരുദമെന്തെന്ന് നോക്കാം.
    http://www.spacecenter.org/SpaceSchool.html
    ഒരു കൂട്ടം തല്പരവിദ്യാര്ത്ഥി കളില്‍ ഉത്സാഹം വളര്ത്താ നായി നല്കു/ന്ന അവസരമാണ് സ്പേസ് സ്കൂളിലെ ഈ പ്രോഗ്രാം. ഇതില്‍ പങ്കെടുക്കുന്നവര്ക്ക് ഡീഫാള്ട്ട്ല ആയി ഒരു ഗ്രാജ്വേഷന്‍ സര്ട്ടിിഫിക്കറ്റ് നല്കുടന്നു എന്ന് ഞാന്‍ അനുമാനിക്കുന്നു.
    ആസ്ത്രേല്യയിലെ Young Astronauts Australia Engineering School ഇതിനു വേണ്ടി വിദ്യാര്ത്ഥി കളെ ക്ഷണിച്ചത് ഇവിടെ കാണാം.
    Australian Science students who are thinking of following a career in either science, technology
    or engineering to apply for this NASA Space Engineering course to be conducted at NASA’s
    Johnson Space Center Houston from September 26th to October 6th 2009. On completion of the course students will receive their graduation certificate.
    സംഗതി പത്തു ദിവസത്തെ പരിപാടിയാണ്. അവരുടെ വിജ്ഞാപനത്തിലെ ചെലവുവിവരം ഇവിടെ.

    “ചൊവ്വയുടെ ഭ്രമണപഥത്തിലെത്താന്‍ കഴിയുന്ന റോക്കറ്റ് ഹൂസ്റ്റണില്‍ വച്ച് ഹനാന്‍ സ്വയം രൂപകല്പന ചെയ്തു. പരീക്ഷണാര്ത്ഥംണ നാസ ഇത് സ്വല്പദൂരത്തേക്ക് വിക്ഷേപിക്കുകയും ചെയ്തു. റോബോട്ടുകള്ക്കും റോവറുകള്ക്കുംു ഹനാന്‍ രൂപകല്പന നല്കി. ചൊവ്വയുടെ ഉപരിതലത്തില്‍ ഇറക്കാനുള്ള റോവറിന്റെ നിര്മ്മാ ണത്തില്‍ പങ്കാളിയാണിപ്പോള്‍.” (മാതൃഭൂമി)
    ഇന്ത്യ വിക്ഷേപിച്ച ഓരോ റോക്കറ്റും ഇന്ത്യന്മ്ഹാസമുദ്രത്തില്‍ അലമാല തീര്ത്തുമ കൊണ്ടിരുന്ന കാലത്ത് കോഴിക്കോട്ട് പിറന്നു വീണ പെണ്കുതട്ടി പതിനഞ്ചു വര്ഷടത്തെ ലോകപരിചയം കൊണ്ട് റോക്കറ്റ് രൂപകല്പന ചെയ്തെന്നു വായിച്ചപോളാണ് എനിക്കീ വാര്ത്തോയെപ്പറ്റി സംശയം തോന്നിത്തുടങ്ങിയത്. വസ്തുതകളെ തെറ്റിദ്ധാരണാജനകമായ രീതിയില്‍ എഴുതിച്ചേര്ത്തി്രിക്കുന്നത് എഴുത്തുകാരിയെങ്കില്‍ അവരും പ്രസിദ്ധപ്പെടുത്താന്‍ അനുമതി നല്കിരയത് പത്രാധിപരെങ്കില്‍ അവരും ഇതിന് വിശദീകരണം നല്കാന്‍ ബാദ്ധ്യസ്ഥരാണ്.
    നേരത്തെ കണ്ട ആസ്ത്രേല്യക്കാര്‍ പറയുന്നതു പ്രകാരം സ്പേസ് സ്കൂളില്‍ രൂപകല്പന ചെയ്ത റോക്കറ്റ് ഇങ്ങനെയാണ്.

    Image Courtesy: http://www.yassa.com.au/protected/day4.html
    മുഴുവന്‍ ചിത്രങ്ങളും ഇവിടെ കാണാം.
    ഹനാനെ ഗൂഗിളില്‍ തിരഞ്ഞപ്പോളാണ് ഇങ്ങനെ ഒരു ആര്ട്ടിങക്കിള്‍ ശ്രദ്ധയില്‍ പെട്ടത്:
    ഇതില്‍ “Absolute Theory of Zero is a new mathematical system which explains the established theories in a different light. Through the theory I’m trying to explain that the speed of light is not constant always,” she explains.
    തന്റെa തിയറിയിലൂടെ പ്രകാശത്തിന്റെe വേഗം മാറിക്കൊണ്ടിരിക്കുന്നു എന്നാണ് ഹനാന്‍ പറയാനുദ്ദേശിക്കുന്നത്. ഹനാന് അഞ്ചു വയസ്സു പ്രായമുള്ളപ്പോള്‍ വന്നതെന്നു വിശ്വസിക്കാവുന്ന ഒരു വാര്ത്തി ഇവിടെ.
    John Moffat എന്നൊരാള്‍ അന്ന്, 1999ല്‍ പറഞ്ഞ ഒരു ഊഹമാണിത്.
    ഈ മാതൃഭൂമി വാര്ത്ത ഞാന്‍ പൂര്ണ്ണ മായി വിശ്വസിച്ചേനെ, ഇത്രക്കും അവിശ്വസനീയത കലര്ത്തി യിരുന്നില്ലെങ്കില്‍. പറഞ്ഞതില്‍ പലതും അര്ദ്ധസസത്യങ്ങളെന്നു കണ്ടതോടെ, പറഞ്ഞ മറ്റു പലതും അസത്യമായേക്കുമോ എന്നു ഭയപ്പെട്ടു പോവുകയാണ് കുഞ്ഞു ഹനാന്‍ ഞാന്‍. കലാമിന്റൊ അംഗീകാരവും ഒബാമയുടെ ക്ഷണവും നീല്‍ ആംസ്ടോങ്ങിന്റെപ നിന്നെ കാണണമെന്ന ആഗ്രഹവുമുള്പ്പെമടെ.
    ഈ വാര്ത്തക സാമാന്യപ്രതിഭാമതികളായ വിദ്യാര്ത്ഥി കളിലുണ്ടാക്കിയേക്കാവുന്ന പ്രത്യാഘാതങ്ങളെക്കുറിച്ചും ഭയപ്പെട്ടു പോവുന്നു. ഹനാനെ മാതൃകയാക്കി മൂന്നു മണിക്ക് ഉറക്കമുണര്ന്ന്ു ബാത്ത് ടബ്ബില്‍ കിടക്കാന്‍ പിഞ്ചുകുഞ്ഞുങ്ങളോടാവശ്യപ്പെടാന്‍ മടിയില്ലാത്ത മാതാപിതാക്കളുള്ള നാട്ടിലാണ് ഞാന്‍ ജീവിക്കുന്നത് എന്നതു കൊണ്ടു വിശേഷിച്ചും.
    എന്തെങ്കിലും കാരണവശാല്‍ ഈ വാര്ത്തനയില്‍ വസ്തുതാപരമായ പിശകുകള്‍ വന്നു ചേര്ന്നികട്ടുണ്ടെങ്കില്‍ അതു തിരുത്തി മാതൃക കാണിക്കാന്‍ മാതൃഭൂമി തയാറാവുമെന്ന് പ്രതീക്ഷിക്കുന്നു.
    പത്രമാദ്ധ്യമങ്ങള്‍ വിരിച്ചു തരുന്ന പ്രശസ്തിയുടെ മെത്തയില്‍ കിടന്ന് ഹനാന്‍ തന്റെന പ്രതിഭയെ നശിപ്പിക്കാതിരിക്കട്ടെ എന്നു മാത്രം ആഗ്രഹിക്കുന്നു.

  • ali shab said:

    congrats hanan i am proud of u we indians are always with u

  • GOPINATH said:

    Dr Ha! Hannan
    congradulation ……..
    hannan u havedone a great thing for our country, greater news has to come along. wonderful amazing , unique, grace from God.
    god bless u…`

    gopinath

  • Hannumaan said:

    This is absolute nonsense. all these claims are FALSE and stupidity in front of the science.

    This is a hyped media report, which is reported by mathrubhoomi sub editor named sissi jacob.

    The court and laws of this country should take actions against such non-existing news and hypes which is not true, and it can lead people in to understand the facts in a wrong way.

    Hannan is making fake claims.

    Anybody can please explain how one can get admission in MIT after passing the 10th standard from India?

    Its a great joke.

    Hannan, you are fake!!!
    sissy jacob, please don’t do such reports. people will sue you for this.

  • Sujith said:

    What the ****, are you nuts, believing all these fake stories by media and ya 90% of the posts praising her are muslims just doing that because she is a muslim. Hannan is making fake claims.
    Theory of zero???????????????? my foot… Hannan please try to pass your class exams first ha ha ha ha

  • Scientist said:

    This is insane…. as a mater of fact Einstein could publish his Theory of relativity only at the age of 25 and how could this girl produce a theory like… and Einstein and Da Vincci are considered to be only two legendary geniuses the world ever come across..

    This is for sure a media make over… and a literal foolishness…

  • laptopxpert said:

    Sceptics need to know :
    Age and intelligence are not related.
    Scientific breakthroughs do not occur when following the beaten path. There has to be a different perspective of the world to see things that were unseen.

    And finally,
    there would be significantly less scepticism, if a single bit about the report was changed – that she was Indian. Had the report said that Hannah was a 14 year old US citizen, no one would have doubted the report.

  • Surgit Singh said:

    ‘I don’t know how these religious fanatics becoming successful in misinterpreting stupids like you. ‘

    This is a rather disrespectful statement, I think, although I agree with your overall theme. Also, you need a verb in the sentence.

    Jesus did claim that he is God, and equal to God; not only the ‘Son of God’

    ‘here the foolish common people with low intelligence doesnt even know the difference between science and technology.everyone is telling even kalam doesnt understand her.kalam is after all an aerospace engineer.what has he to do with theoretical physics????’

    Again, just because they do not have the necessary knowledge about Lorentz transformation or various space constructs, whether it is Banach, Hilbert or Minkowski, does not mean common people are foolish. It is OK to be an admirer of theoretical physics, but other fields, mathematics, chemistry, engineering, medicine, and yes economics are all important and interesting. There are a lot of things theoretical physicists do not know; and they cannot easily find a good job, if they are not extremely good. Unless you put everything fundamental under the umbrella of theoretical physics, most of the progress in our living standards are not the direct result of theoretical physics; they are from experimental physics, chemistry, engineering, medicine, biology, and even economics. If a subject cannot play a significant role in improving our living standards, one has to wonder about its importance.

    On the main subject, I do not understand why Hannan is seeking such a publicity. This is not at all helpful.

  • A P Jamal said:

    Dear Hanaan,

    You know the TRUTH! One cannot berry the TRUTH, though you can hide it for a while! MIT, when are you joining? BTW do you know the grade 10th Exam is arround the corner, which is the FACT!

    All The best

    Jamal.

  • Sujith said:

    @A P Jamal
    You are a BIG FOOL please read this before praising her
    Mathrubhumi
    http://epaper.mathrubhumi.com/index.php?id=7602&cat=14&date=2009-10-05
    bottom left hand corner
    I know why you are praising her because you and she are muslims…

  • Surgit Singh said:

    May be this will give a clue: From
    http://talkislam.wordpress.com/2006/05/29/quantum-physics-confirms-islam/

    What Hannan say here is (entire post is attached below) – No-one can be against Islam, because no one can be against Allah.
    ***
    MAY be other religion can fight against Islam.but all the non believers will see that islam is only truth. And I am nt rejecting any religion, islam is the best, islam shows what is right. and no-one can be against it, no one can be against allah , even non-believers,will believe in allah. evry religion will praise islam. I dont want any feedback.this is true,the perfect, and special note for all non believers, science is just a testing of quranic concepts.and not quranic concepts are proven by science, almost 80%. I never forces people to convert your religion to islam, but this could be best.nt bcoz i am a muslim, but I feel the divine power of allah ,that made for all non-believers not to stick to convictions.there is no need of proof for existence of allah.he is one.and just see the universe around, therois around, yet no theories have bcome most comprehensible with quran.trust in allah -almighty,because he exists.DIVINE POWER.
    i just hate other religion criticising islam,that should nt be done, not that this religion should be called liars,there cn be , but not all muslims,dont use unneccesary language or discourage muslims in their belief in allah.
    If u cant comprehend the infiniteness of allah , how can you comprehend the infiniteness of creator if you cant divide infinity into 2/3, how can you believe in his trinity/? where is all mathematcians,scientists in his oneness.
    pls nt: other religions might not know islam well, so does the non-believers.you may feel to argue, but therse is no point,you will recognize,and please dont blabber over facts on islam which you dont know.
    speak what is right.
    reffering to marks comment.you have said, allah is light. yeah tthts rite.light is energy.but allah is not reduced to state of light.he is force,the singularity.absolute extreme absolute force, and not like ordinary forces.u gt me? believe it.
    regards
    Hanaan
    Hanaan Bint Hashim – April 19, 2009 at 10:55 pm

  • Surgit Singh said:

    In spite of all the criticism, she is still going with the absolute theory of zero. See this quote from the same web page on Dec 13.
    ****
    Hi ali,
    U might be against me..People will be against Islam..not all but,There are things which couldnt express..U know u r talking abt a force and extra-ordinary force..diffference.What is all this upto..doesnt make a sense..But trust me..force is not an end..light is nt an end too..This is what u cant express in reality..Tell me ,have u found any theory which is perfectly fit?answer is no…U cant..u wont..bcoz this universe is constantly having a change.
    Coming to ur questions :
    1) How will an explosion like Big bang occur if there is no extra ordinary force acting on it..How can that cause rise to millions of universe..If it was an ordinary force acting on it..do u think universe is going to born Perfectly and strictly not.
    There you go wrong..u cant compare allahs light to torch or sun light..extra ordinary light which I am talking about..

    a force is a push or pull acting on a body..what makes it differnt from super force or extra ordinary force is the reality of Universe..
    We dont realize the fact bcoz we hardly knew about it in expressing it in physics..there will be an end for physics..so trust me…there will be an end for all physics terms and concepts too.that surely makes a sense.

    In my absolute theory of zero,I never explained about a torch light.there is where all go wrong.I am talking about that has already taken in past..I am not anyone wrong..even Einstein..AS for my side…his experiments are treated as the biggest ever.But u see..in macro level this wont happen..
    light upon light is allahs light..and u dont know what it is..people doesnt know…I even dont know…so does the great scientist..Astrophysics reached a barrier where it could explain..in physics terms…but till that reach a barrier that has way to go..but all this is going to be an end..

    U need sumthng totally away from Physics..which explains this ,still Its hard to find a perfect..for Allah knows everything..

    U should make sense,I cant be perfect in my theory..and even no can be..there will be drawbacks in my theory as I accept it as part of reality.

    nd I agree to u perfectly for this word of urs.
    Human minds developed science.. ergo, by simple deductive reasoning, God must have created science beforehand for us humans to discover it and witness the truth of the universe and the truth of his existence.
    This is how it makes so perfect sense to me that everything exists and is created by God, the Greatest.

    that really makes sense …and thats gud view of point..
    REgards
    Hanaan
    Hanaan Bint Hashim – December 13, 2009 at 4:30 am

  • ISMAYIL said:

    congradulations & all the best. God bless you.

  • Galleria Photography said:

    Dr H!
    congradulation ……..
    hannan u havedone a great thing for our country also our Stat of Kerala, greater news has to come along.
    wonderful amazing , unique, grace from God.
    god bless u…`keep on going.

    Galleria Photography Management & Staff
    Vatakara – Kozhikode

  • AP Jamal said:

    @Sujith,

    I happend to read your commends only today, but sad to see that you completely lost your humour! By this time the whole world realized that “Hanaan is nothing but a Fraud” and many of her sponsors have withdrawn her support, and that what I meant by the word “You Know the TRUTH”. I am sure she is realizing her mistakes by now, especially after her recent trip to US and knocking the doors for HELP! Her famous presentations the biggest nonsense I have ever heard in my life.. Why do you think our Dr. Abdul Kalam failed to understand Hanaan??? Because there was no SUBSTANCE or MATTER in her talk or discussion, just the book / internet knowledge, that’s it!! May be you are not aware, she has been visiting the most prestigious libraries in south India just to read the astrophysics related books! That’s all !!!

    Being said all the above, I still belie that Hanaan is an extra brilliant girl but lack of direction! Also, it is a shame to hear that she don’t have any fundamental values in her, which is being discussed among her friends and family!! I hope she can appear for her Xth board exam, though she did not stick to the school attendance (Yes,she got an Exception from Govt for school attendance till Dec’09) with out any other issues.

    That’s all for now…

    Luv all, AP Jamal.

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.